I’m not going to tell you that you can’t do your own estate plan. You can. In most states, a handwritten will is technically valid as long as it’s signed and witnessed properly. Online services will generate documents for a few hundred dollars. There are books, templates, and YouTube videos that walk you through it.
So can you? Yes. Should you? That depends on your situation — and on whether you understand the difference between having documents and having a plan that works.
When DIY can work
I’ll be honest about this. If you have a genuinely simple situation, a basic online will is better than nothing. Better than nothing is a real thing in estate planning — because “nothing” means your state’s default rules apply, and those rules may not match what you want.
DIY might be adequate if all of the following are true:
- You’re single with no children
- You don’t own real estate
- Your assets are modest and mostly held in accounts with named beneficiaries (retirement accounts, life insurance)
- You have straightforward wishes — “everything to my sister”
- You don’t need any tax planning
If that describes you, an online will and a basic power of attorney might be enough for now. I’d rather you have something than wait for the “perfect” plan.
When it breaks down
The problem with DIY estate planning isn’t the documents themselves — it’s that estate planning is more than documents. It’s a system of interlocking pieces, and if one piece doesn’t connect to the others, the whole thing can fail in ways you won’t discover until it’s too late.
The will that doesn’t match the trust
This is the most common problem I see. Someone buys a trust and a will from an online service. The trust exists. The will exists. But the will doesn’t actually reference the trust. It doesn’t “pour over” into it. So when the person dies, the will directs assets one way and the trust sits empty. The family ends up in probate anyway — which was the entire thing the trust was supposed to prevent.
The person paid a few hundred dollars for documents that didn’t work together. Their goals weren’t complicated. The execution just didn’t match the intention.
The deed that never transferred
You create a trust. The trust document says it should hold your house. But a trust doesn’t own your house just because the trust document mentions real property. You need a new deed — typically a quitclaim deed — transferring ownership from your name to the trust’s name. That deed has to be prepared correctly, signed, notarized, and recorded with the county.
Most online services either don’t include this step or include a form that the client never completes. The trust exists on paper. The house is still in the individual’s name. Probate.
The beneficiary designation that contradicts everything
Your will says everything goes to your children equally. But your retirement account beneficiary form — the one you filled out when you started your job twelve years ago — still names your ex-spouse. The beneficiary designation wins. It overrides the will. It overrides the trust. Your ex-spouse gets the retirement account, regardless of what your will says.
This isn’t a flaw in the system. It’s how beneficiary designations are designed to work. But if nobody reviews them as part of the estate plan, nobody catches the conflict until it’s too late to fix.
The pattern: In every one of these cases, the person did the work. They created documents. They spent money. They thought they were done. The problem wasn’t effort or intelligence — it was that nobody checked whether all the pieces actually fit together.
What an attorney actually does that’s different
The documents are part of it — but honestly, the documents are the easy part. What you’re paying an attorney for is the thinking: understanding your situation, identifying the gaps, and building a plan where every piece connects.
A will that references your trust. A trust that’s actually funded with your assets. Beneficiary designations that align with the rest of your plan. A power of attorney that covers what it needs to cover in your state. A healthcare directive that reflects your actual wishes. All of these things working together, checked by someone who understands not just the legal requirements but also the tax implications and the financial picture.
That’s what you’re paying for. Not the paper.
The cost question
People often compare the cost of an attorney to the cost of an online service and see a big gap. An online will might be $150. An attorney-drafted will-based plan might be $1,500. That feels like a tenfold difference.
But the comparison isn’t $150 vs. $1,500. The comparison is $150 (with a meaningful chance the plan doesn’t work) vs. $1,500 (with confidence that it does). And if the $150 plan fails, the cost of fixing it — probate, court fees, attorney fees for your family — is typically $10,000 to $20,000 or more.
The most expensive estate plan is the one that doesn’t work.
Not sure what you need?
Submit a short intake form. I’ll give you an honest assessment of your situation — including whether you actually need an attorney.
Request a Consultation